Showing posts with label miracles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label miracles. Show all posts

Thursday, August 18, 2016

Pope Francis is Boring

"Sharing is good"

This morning, Pope Francis claimed that the miracle of the multiplication of the loaves and fishes was really about sharing. This was at least the fourth time he's publicly made this claim as Pope, and only God knows how often he did so as bishop or mere priest.
“He shows them that the few loaves and fishes they have, with the power of faith and of prayer, can be shared by all the people,” the Pope said. “It is a miracle that he does, but it is the miracle of faith, of prayer with compassion and love.” 
“Jesus wishes to withdraw and pray, but seeing the multitudes, is moved by compassion and chooses to remain with them. By instructing his disciples to feed the crowd, he teaches them to have faith and invites them to share in his concern for those in need,” he continued. “The miracle of the multiplication of the loaves and fishes is a concrete sign of that merciful concern.”
In other words, it's not really a miracle. Rather it shows that Jesus cared and (it follows) we should care too.

Francis is denying that the miracle, in the sense that we usually understand the meaning of the term "miracle," ever happened.

As all of you know, the story - which occurs six times in the Gospels - is that Jesus miraculously multiplied a few loaves and fishes to feed thousands. It's the second most famous miracle in the New Testament - the only miracle outside of the Resurrection to be recorded in all four Gospels.

Why is it a miracle? Well, this is obvious to any five-year-old. A few loaves and fish cannot feed thousands, no matter how you divide or distribute them and no matter how much anyone cares. Jesus - because He had miraculous powers - simply created more loaves and fish ex nihilo. Poof! It was magic, or sort of magic. Christians don't usually like that that term because it implies there might be something occult or tricky going on. But, in common sense language, magic gets it mostly right. If you prefer, substitute the term supernatural.

The common-sense understanding of the significance of the miracle was that this was a sign that Jesus was a special man, or more than just a man (at the time of the miracle, no one, or almost no one, understood that Jesus was in fact God). That there would be and were such signs, is alluded to many times in the Bible. The Christian Fathers unanimously understood the miracle in this way.

Now, there are reasons why the sign had the characteristics that it had - why Jesus on this occasion created food out of nothing. Why did He perform this miracle instead of, say, levitating over the crowd or disappearing in a cloud of smoke or whatever?

There are two answers, I think. The first is that it recalled Moses calling manna from Heaven. In the Old Testament, Moses caused or participated in a similar miracle. If Jesus was special, he should at least be able to do what Moses did. This sign showed that Jesus was the new Moses, or, as it would of course be later revealed, much more than Moses.

The second is that all of the miracles of Jesus were not merely arbitrary marvels, but were also symbols or representations of what God does for us as a matter of course. We don't usually see bread and seafood appearing out of nowhere. But God feeds us "normal" food every day, and He gives us the bread of life at communion. Even the Resurrection is a miracle of this kind. We don't usually see dead people getting up and walking (except in movies) but, if certain conditions hold, God will in the end resurrect us and give us eternal life.

For Pope Francis, the "miracle" was really Jesus teaching us about sharing.

Pardon me for saying so, but that would make Christianity the stupidest religion ever. I don't (pardon me, again)  need some Jewish hippy from 2,000 years ago telling me that sharing is a lovely thing. And neither do you. Both of us knew that moral principle already. Try evangelizing an atheist by saying, look, there was this guy in the first century who said sharing was good. Be prepared to die for Him as a martyr. The atheist would (rightly) look at you as if you were crazy.

We might call this the Faber University version of Christianity:
Sharing is Good.
Now, obviously, I don't think Jesus was merely a Jewish hippy. No true Christian does. But Pope Francis seems to think so. There are no miracles, only teachings. And they're pretty obvious teachings. Sharing is good.

And Francis is the man, 2,000 years later to remind us of that fact. Just think, we used to think Christianity was all about anathemas.

As far as I could tell, no Catholic bloggers (at least the ones on my feed) cited this latest howler. That's not to fault them. Far from it. It's rather, evidence that no one is surprised anymore. The Pope denies another fundamental element of the Catholic faith and makes Christianity dull. Ho hum. What else is new?

I almost didn't write this, for the same reason that other Catholic bloggers didn't write about it. It's not news. It's boring.

The enigmatic Bishop Barron has written that our faith in Christ should set us on fire. Forget, for the moment, the claims that Francis is an anti-Pope or a proto-anti-Christ or (as I have said) the most dangerous man from the point of view of the health of the Catholic Church alive today.

Think of him rather as that awful third-grade teacher that you had. He could make anything boring and unappealing. Vikings are cool and exciting. But you'll always hate vikings because you can't get the memory out of your head of Mr. Milquetoast droning on and on about them.

And when you nodded off or wrote notes to your friends in class, Mr. Milquetoast reprimanded you for not paying attention to his tedious monologue. It's your fault, you see. No one else taught the vikings correctly. He is finally doing so. That you are snoring or throwing spitballs during his lecture shows that you are unappreciative.

Please.

Francis doesn't help to set you on fire. He puts you to sleep.

God (and His Son) is the most fascinating subject there is. Read the Gospels, They are a window on the most amazing thing that ever happened.

Once, God walked among us as a man.

And if you follow Him, you can live with Him forever.

Don't listen to Francis - he'll ruin it for you.

Tuesday, July 14, 2015

Why Didn't God Pay Her Restaurant Tab?

Should she have cleared it with Him before ordering?

From News2 (NBC Affiliate, South Carolina):
MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WBTW) – A woman was arrested Sunday night after refusing to pay her dinner tab at a Myrtle Beach seafood restaurant because, as she explained to police, “Jesus” was going to cover the cost of her meal. 
Myrtle Beach Police were called to Bennetts Calabash just after 9 p.m. Sunday night when, according to the incident report, 51-year-old April Lee Yates was asked to leave by management, but refused to do so. The report states that Yates was in the restaurant for nearly four hours before she started to cause a disturbance with other patrons. Management asked Yates to pay her dinner tab and leave, but she refused to pay the $26 bill. 
When the officer asked Yates if she had any money to pay, Yates said she did not. The officer then asked Yates what she planned to do with the bill came, and Yates explained that “Jesus” was going to pay her tab. 
Yates was arrested for defrauding a restaurant and booked into the Myrtle Beach jail.
I hope I'm not being irreverent with the post title. But after all, God could have paid her tab (He's God), and not even in an obvious or dramatic way--perhaps by causing a "forgotten" $26 to be found in her pocket, for example, or in softening the heart of the manager on duty so that he would have prevailed on the police to give her a pass or whatever--but He didn't.

Don't laugh, but I actually think it's an interesting question to ask why, especially given the Pope's recent homily on the miracle of the loaves and fishes. And no this isn't (thank God) an anti-Francis post.

Don't answer if you don't believe in God, because then the answer's obvious and trivial. But if you do believe in God, then seriously,

Why didn't God pay her tab?

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Then the Lord Now Spoke: "Boko Haram is Gone."


I think it's safe to say that even faithful traditionalist Christians and Catholics, the sorts of people that believe the miracles in the Bible actually happened (as opposed to the modernist tripe that the miracle descriptions are all mere allegories or whatever), often do not believe that "large-scale" miracles--pillars of fire, seas parting and so on--currently happen. Or rather, while there might be occasional cases--the "dancing sun" at Fatima, for instance--they appear to be in some sense disconnected from other historical events. The allies won the First World War not with a dancing sun but with guns and bullets. Or so it would seem.

Indeed, I think there's almost a distaste for desiring "large-scale" intervention, whether visible or not. You want God to help the "good-guys" gain a majority in Congress? How narrow of you. Doesn't God have better things to do? Why not ask for His grace to help you go a bit easier on your drinking or whatever. And wouldn't such an exercise of Divine power interfere with people's free will, to say nothing of letting us off the hook as God's committed soldiers down here on Earth?

I think these thoughts and worries have merit, but they do not express the entire truth. Post-biblical "large-scale" miracles do happen. The 16th century miraculously created image of Our Lady of Gaudalupe was said to have been responsible for converting 9 million native Americans to the Christian faith. The missionaries bravely and tirelessly carried out their tasks. Many of them died. But they had help.

Much of Christian Nigeria is currently under vicious and sustained assault by Boko Haram, a truly Satanic movement if there ever was one. Scarcely a day goes by without a report of another massacre, another village destroyed, with its men shot, hacked or burned to death and its women abducted into slavery. Evil seems to have, so to speak, the momentum.

But reports have recently come out of, well, a miracle. One hesitates to even state it, as if it would jinx it or something. Or perhaps, we have the fear that it's too good to be true. A hoax, perhaps.

The Catholic News Agency released a video of the testimony of a Nigerian bishop--Bishop Oliver Dashe Doeme, head of the Diocese of Miduguri in Nigeria's Borno State--who claims to have had an apparition of Jesus. I recommend watching the short (2:32) interview, partly because the bishop's sincerity is obvious and his joy is infectious. But I have also transcribed it below.


I said, towards the end of last year, one evening I was praying in my chapel before the Blessed Sacrament. The Blessed Sacrament is for us twenty-four hours--perpetual adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. 
So, I was there before the Blessed Sacrament, praying the Rosary. And then suddenly, the Lord appeared and I saw him--Hallelu!--this is Jesus with a sword in His own hand! And I started trembling. I said, "Lord, what is this?" He didn't say anything. He just stretched out his arms with the sword in his hands towards me. And then I also stretched my hands and received the sword. As soon as I received the sword it turned into a Rosary. It turned into the Rosary. 
Then, the Lord now spoke: "Boko Haram is gone. Boko Haram is gone. Boko Haram is gone." Three times, He said that and then he disappeared. 
I didn't need any prophet to give me this explanation. It was clear. That with the Rosary we would be able to expel Boko Haram from our diocese. That, with the intervention of His own mother whom I so cherish whom I am so close to, and then if I encourage our own people to do the same thing, we will dislodge Boko Haram. 
And that is exactly what is happening. Most of this part of out diocese that was under Boko Haram have been reclaimed and our people have started coming back. 
So what does that prove? Does one need to know that, yes, the message the Lord brought is correct? And as I've said, it's not because I'm an extraordinary person, the very wonderful bishop. No, it has nothing to do with that. The Lord just brought His message to (unclear) someone who could do this--to his own people so that the people would be strengthened, especially at this trying moment in their own lives as a people, and then as a Church. 
And that's exactly what has happened. So, I want to thank my Blessed Mother Mary. I want to thank Jesus Christ Her Son. I want to thank the Trinity. I am nothing. I am nothing. Just a very very simple servant of the Lord.
Steve Skojec at OnePeterFive recently picked up on this story, following a report from Church Militant. But yesterday, Steve added a crucial piece to it: 
Fast-forward one month, and the position of Boko Haram in Nigeria appears to have all but collapsed (my emphasis). Gbenga Akingbule, reporting for the Wall Street Journal, describes the sudden and surprising turn of events: 
"Boko Haram has abandoned so many hundreds of kidnapped women and girls recently that Nigerian officials tasked with bringing them back into society on Sunday said they were looking to open a second rehabilitation camp, a nod to how fast the tide of abductions has reversed. In the past few weeks, as troops from Nigeria and surrounding countries have punched deep into Boko Haram territory, soldiers said they have rescued about 1,000 women and girls, hostages the Islamist insurgency left behind. They include about 275 that army pickup trucks brought into the city of Yola on Saturday night and 260 rescued on Sunday."
I think it's fair to say that the mood among faithful Catholics concerning the recent "successes" of ISIS, Boko Haram and Muslim aggression in general, is grim. The consensus seems to be that we are experiencing a new and heightened phase of Christian martyrdom, which will only get worse. God is on our side, as always of course, but first, great suffering seems to be part of the plan--a necessary chastisement or purification, perhaps.

There's no question that that's at least partly true. But maybe it's not the full story. Maybe, at least for some of the worst affected, there can be an end to it. Now. 
Boko Haram is gone. Boko Haram is gone. Boko Haram is gone.
One can hope. And pray.